the word of the Lord: "A great clamour," says Dr. Kennicott, "has been raised against this part of history, on account of God's denouncing sentence on the true prophet by the mouth of the false prophet; but if we examine with attention the original words here, they will be found to signify either he who brought him back, or, whom he had brought back; for the very same words, asher heshivo:, occur again, 1 Kings 13:23, where they are now translated, whom he had brought back; and where they cannot be translated otherwise.
This being the case, we are at liberty to consider the words of the Lord as delivered to the true prophet, thus brought back; and then the sentence is pronounced by God himself, calling to him out of heaven, as in Genesis 22:11.
And that this doom was thus pronounced by God, not by the false prophet, we are assured in 1 Kings 13:26. 'The Lord hath delivered him unto the lion, according to the word of the Lord, which He spake unto him.'
Josephus (and also the Arabic) asserts, that the sentence was declared by God to the true prophet."